A Canadian court has ruled that the government harmed thousands of indigenous children who were robbed of their cultural heritage when it took them from their families. Launched eight years ago, the lawsuit could cost the government US$1bn.
Ruling on the case on Tuesday, Justice Edward Belobaba said Canada breached its “duty of care” when the Ontario-led program forcibly removed 16,000 aboriginal children from their families and relocated them to non-indigenous homes between 1965 and 1984.
Protesting the lack of equity and action to aboriginal communities especially in education #haveaheartday #canada #parlimenthill #aboriginalrights #protest
A post shared by Rowan Hurtubise (@creativementalist) on
Rally this morning marking survivors of the Sixties Scoop first day in court in their class action lawsuit against the Ontario government for failing to protect indigenous children taken from their families between 1960 and 1980. 16, 000 children were scooped in Ontario alone. #sixtiesscoop #rally #onpoli #idlenomore #honouryourwords #trudeau #indigenous #rights
A post shared by Cordelia Huxtable (@cordeliahh) on
The federal initiative, which aimed to educate children on Euro-Canadian and Christian values, became known as the ‘Sixties Scoop’. An investigation into the program produced the Kimelman Report, which described it as “cultural genocide.”
"The uncontroverted evidence of the plaintiff's experts is that the loss of their Aboriginal identity left the children fundamentally disoriented, with a reduced ability to lead healthy and fulfilling lives,” Belobaba said, as quoted by CBC.
“The loss of Aboriginal identity resulted in psychiatric disorders, substance abuse, unemployment, violence and numerous suicides.”
“There is … no dispute that great harm was done,” the judge added.
When asked if Feds will appeal '60s Scoop decision, @Carolyn_Bennett says: "absolutely not."
— Omar Sachedina (@omarsachedina) February 14, 2017
The case had stuttered for several years until Prime Minister Justin Trudeau came to power, fulfilling an election promise that it would be revived to better the country’s relationship with its indigenous population. Tuesday’s ruling is expected to have an impact on a number of similar cases across the country.
READ MORE: Canada’s energy regulator approves Trans Mountain pipeline despite First Nation, Green backlash
Damages have yet to be decided upon.
Thank you @sixtiesscoop We will use this great decision to honour you and to help this generation of children. https://t.co/QuAkymWrQF
— Cindy Blackstock (@cblackst) February 14, 2017
National Chief of the Assembly of First Nations Perry Bellegarde welcomed the decision, telling Reuters: "Children have the right to speak their language and stay connected to their heritage. Today's decision is a step towards reconciliation."
Marcia Brown Martel, who was taken from her native family aged four, began the class-action lawsuit against the federal government when she began searching for her roots. No information had been provided to Martel’s adoptive family on her original home, leaving her to try tracing her past from her limited memories.
#SixtiesScoop Chief Marcia Brown 'Canada today became a better country' pic.twitter.com/XH1ofpjhvs
— Chiefs of Ontario (@ChiefsofOntario) February 14, 2017
Reacting to the ruling, Colleen Cardinal, who was also taken as part of the program when she was just two years old, said she was surprised with the ruling but is now confident that similar lawsuits will go the same way.
"I think the rest of the country has been waiting for this class action to be resolved, and I'm pretty sure that the rest will follow suit," she told CBC.
BREAKING NEWS: Ontario judge ruled that Canada failed thousands of on-reserve kids who lost Indigenous heritage during the Sixties Scoop. pic.twitter.com/lm2900NGrZ
— Dustin McGladrey🌲 (@DustinMcGladrey) February 14, 2017
Cardinal said this was a “monetary victory” but that those taken still needed support to help them heal.
A number of children taken during the program were adopted by US families, including Sydney Dion, who was denied entry to Canada when he attempted to return home as he did not have a Canadian birth certificate. He was eventually allowed to enter the country after border patrol acknowledged he was a minor when taken to the US and did not consent to becoming a US citizen.